Happy Meeple forum

Our games => Lost Cities => Topic started by: Jamie A. on 16/05/17, 08:48am

Title: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jamie A. on 16/05/17, 08:48am
I've been unable to figure out the "Expedition scoring" page subtotals more than a few times and assumed it was me, given the many (many) experienced players here. But now I've given up, I just don't understand the logic.

Please advise! and thank you.
Title: Re: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jimmy V. on 16/05/17, 09:09am
Well, indeed, that's weird!!!

The 148 should be 108 (4X27). Then the bonus of 20 is added to get to the correct final score 128.

Well spotted. I wonder why noone ever complained about it. Maybe it only occurs in certain instances.

Anyone else has seen this?
Title: Re: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jamie A. on 16/05/17, 11:12am
Thank you, I'm glad to know it's not me! Here's another just played, it's the green cards. They both might be the green cards.

Title: Re: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jimmy V. on 16/05/17, 05:39pm
Again, it added 40 points unnecessarily.

What is your browser?
Title: Re: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jamie A. on 17/05/17, 06:33am
Most often I play on a Firefox 45.0.2 eme-free.

Sometimes I play on another browser or another computer and I will try to check there for the error. I can tell you also, after posting that last screenshot I continued playing LC and didn't see the error again. And that is consistent with prev experience, where only occasionally I would check and only a percentage of those checks would note an odd subtotal.

Lost Cities was new to me so it took a while for me to become comfortable with the scoring and puzzled enough to look further when I happened upon it again.   

UPDT:
If it's the type of issue that you think may just be down to old tech, then I have to be even more judicious about the items brought to your attention. Most sites I use including game playing don't seem affected however your site is newer plus you have probably more advanced AI. My experience is that most things work fine for me and when something doesn't it's fairly obvious as to why. But if the tech here may result in more nuanced issues... well, all I can say is that my intent isn't to cause you unnecessary work or pointless investigation on old tech vs new tech issues and if that is what's happened I'm sorry.
Title: Re: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jimmy V. on 17/05/17, 11:15am
Don't worry! It is most likely not related to your browser. And your help is most appreciated.

It seems to happen only when there is an 8-card bonus anyway. So it is most likely where the issue resides. I'll have to check my code.

In the meantime, if others have an 8-card bonus, I'd like them to check if the computation is right or wrong.

Have fun!
Title: Re: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jamie A. on 17/05/17, 02:27pm
You're quite kind, thank you. Also probably correct about the bonus. I just saw another one that was on the bonus ( 17 x 3 = 91 ) and oddly again also on the green cards.

UPDT: ah, finally got one not on green cards ( 17 x 2 = 74 ) 
Title: Re: Lost Cities Scoring question
Post by: Jimmy V. on 14/06/17, 12:30pm
I have uploaded the fix to correct the issue. Let me know if it still does not work.